Kim Kardashian’s All’s Fair returns with savage reviews - The News International

Critics have again panned All’s Fair, the Ryan Murphy legal drama starring Kim Kardashian.

Season 2 premiered on Hulu and Disney+ on November 4. The first season, which debuted in November 2025, also got harsh reviews.

The Telegraph gave the new season one star. Critic Ed Power said he feels sorry for Glenn Close and Watts. He said Watts starred in Mulholland Drive 25 years ago. Now, he wrote, she is in a show that “might just qualify as the worst TV series of the 21st century.” He said she wears the same brittle smile in every scene.

Ready Steady Cut gave it two stars. Critic Jonathon Wilson said he was confused. He believes the show is not meant to be serious but sometimes acts like it is. He said a camp satire with Kardashian is not the worst idea. But he said a serious legal drama starring her sounds awful.

The Guardian also gave one star. But critic Lucy Mangan admitted she was starting to have fun. She wrote that the show is groping its way toward “so bad it’s good” territory.

Kardashian, 46, has spoken about the first season’s reviews. She said she feared her career might be over. Then viewers tuned in to see how bad it was. She said they made it a number one show for weeks. “I just thought it was so funny that people came in and wanted to hate on it so much,” she said.

The cast also includes Niecy Nash, Sarah Paulson, and Teyana Taylor.