Cyber-libel rice
I still remember reading this line in my older brother Leonie’s high school valedictory speech after nosing around our father’s filing cabinet when I was around 10 years old. It was the answer of a farmer’s young child to my brother on what the boy imagined heaven to be. It was an innocent and bittersweet indictment of the state of Philippine agriculture then. I guess the boy’s answer stuck to Leonie, who subsequently devoted his entire life to try to help make the boy’s dream a reality in the country.
After graduating summa cum laude from the Ateneo, he went straight to join our father in the Federation of Free Farmers (FFF), one of the oldest and the most reputable farmer organizations in the Philippines. He has been with the FFF for over 50 years, served several terms in Congress representing the farmers and even became the secretary of agriculture in the early 2000s.
Leonie is now 77 years old and still trying. The other day, the police went to his house to serve a warrant of arrest. As the song goes, “…planting rice is never fun.” It could even land you in jail.
My brother and others in the farmer sector have been questioning why the Philippine Planter’s Products Inc. (PPI), which they claim appears to be like a government-owned and controlled corporation (GOCC), has been heavily importing rice to the country. Under current laws, particularly RA 11203 and RA 12078, government entities cannot freely import rice except under extraordinary emergency conditions authorized through specific executive orders or presidential action. Historically a fertilizer and agrochemical company, PPI hardly imported any rice prior to 2025. However, it heavily started doing so in 2026. This year, PPI has reportedly imported close to two million sacks of rice worth billions of pesos and has become the second largest rice importer in the Philippines. In response to my brother’s questions, PPI filed a cyber-libel case against him, claiming that it is not a GOCC.
What is interesting is that approximately 80 percent of the shares of PPI is held by Planter’s Foundation Inc. (PFI) which was created by the government. In 1974, the government placed most of PPI’s shares under the custody of PFI “…to be held in trust for millions of Filipino farmers.” PFI is chaired by the incumbent secretary of the Department of Agriculture (DA) who exercises voting rights and nominates candidates to the board of PPI. In a July 2019 post in its own website, the DA described it as “…a private agricultural company sequestered by the government a few years back and is now under the administrative control of the DA.” It has been reported that in several government directories, such as those of the Department of Budget and Management (DBM) and the Governance Commission for GOCCs (GCG), the PPI is listed as a GOCC. Do all these constitute or imply effective government ownership and/or control? I don’t know, you tell me!
I understand that a primary legal basis of PPI’s claim seems to be a 2008 Supreme Court (SC) ruling involving PPI vs Fertiphil Corporation. According to some summaries I read, the SC noted that both PPI and Fertiphil Corporation were private corporations under Philippine laws as part of that decision. I find it ironic that the central decision of that SC ruling was to order PPI to return millions of pesos in “capital recovery” levy it had collected from Fertiphil Corporation during the martial law years. It declared a 1985 Marcos Letter of Instruction (LOI) 1465, which authorized “…the collection of fertilizer levy to bail out and benefit PPI,” as unconstitutional and that to allow PPI to keep it would be “unjust enrichment.”
At the very, very least, PPI’s ownership structure; its apparent treatment as a GOCC by several government agencies and subsequent relevant laws such as the GOCC Governance Act of 2011 (RA 10149) all provide sufficient and good faith bases to question the real status of PPI and destroy any claim of an outright and malicious falsehood.
Moreover, the question is not frivolous and involves a clear and important public interest. Why is it considered malicious for a farmer leader representing rice farmers to question such an entity’s huge imports that they believe threatens the welfare of the country’s rice farmers?
If we ask the young children of farmers today on what they think heaven is like, as my brother did over half a century ago, I wonder what they will answer now.
Sa Pilipinas, madaming imported na bigas?
abtestabtest EDITORIAL— Liberal gun laws October 2, 2026 - 12:00am One detail stood out in a previous hearing of the Senate impeachment court: private gun ownership in this country is exceptionally liberal. Opinion EDITORIAL - Slipping innovation October 4, 2026 - 12:00am After four consecutive years of improving rankings, the Philippines slipped two spots in the latest Global Innovation Index, placing 52nd out of 139 economies in the 2026 GII. Opinion EDITORIAL - No absolute bank secrecy October 6, 2026 - 12:00am The spirited effort to stop the testimony yesterday of the executive director of the Anti-Money Laundering Council during the impeachment trial highlights the need to ease bank secrecy laws. Opinion A blessing in disguise By CTALK | By Cito Beltran | October 14, 2026 - 12:00am News travels fast, bad news travels faster, rumors and gossip the fastest. Opinion Return to FAME By SINGKIT | By Doreen G. Yu | 11 days ago Last week I returned to the Manila FAME trade show after skipping it for several years. Opinion Latest More in Opinion Conflicted MADman on a mission Hope in a sea of hopelessness Project Airbag abtest Clearing Imeldific By SKETCHES | By Ana Marie Pamintuan | 1 day ago In 2003, the Supreme Court ruled that Ferdinand and Imelda Marcos’ legitimate income from their combined salaries during their 20-year rule amounted to only P2.3 million ($304,372 at the time). Opinion Fight not fright By CTALK | By Cito Beltran | 1 day ago As Halloween approaches, some people are busy trying to make the festivities of the dead something to remember. Opinion The pistis shift By ROSES AND THORNS | By Pia Roces Morato | 1 day ago Let’s be honest: life right now feels exhausting. Whether you are scrolling through your phone and seeing non-stop bad news, worrying about the rising price of food and jeepney fares, or just trying to get... Opinion Palace, House collude in P1-trillion pork By GOTCHA | By Jarius Bondoc | 1 day ago The political elite is provoking people to revolt. Opinion Recommended Tax evasion vs VP Sara, nasilip ng prosecution October 30, 2026 - 12:00am Nasilip ng House prosecution panel ang posibleng tax evasion ni Vice President Sara Duterte matapos umanong madiskubre ang P111.85 milyong hindi pagtutugma sa pagitan ng kanyang idineklarang kita at mga depositong...r OpinionSARA DUTERTE Senado at Kamara, pinagkokomento ng SC sa impeachment threshold ni VP Sara October 30, 2026 - 12:00am Inatasan ng Korte Suprema ang Senado at Kamara na magsumite ng kanilang komento sa petisyong inihain nina Sen. Robin Padilla at Sen. Bong Go na kumukuwestiyon sa ruling ng impeachment court hinggil sa voting threshold...r OpinionSARA DUTERTE PANOORIN: NLEX C5 Northlink toll-free hanggang katapusan ng taon — Marcos October 29, 2026 - 11:11am Libre hanggang katapusan ng taon ang pagdaan sa bagong bukas na NLEX C5 Northlink, ayon kay Marcos. OpinionBONGBONG MARCOSINFRASTRUCTURENLEX Barbers kay VP Sara: Ipaliwanag P81.84 milyong insurance, investments October 29, 2026 - 12:00am Hinamon ni House impeachment trial adviser at spokesperson Robert Ace Barbers si Vice President Sara Duterte na ipaliwanag ang umano’y P81.84 milyong transaksyon sa insurance...r OpinionSARA DUTERTE PANOORIN: P15-M na mga relo, ninakaw sa NAIA; mga opisyal, na-Tulfo! October 28, 2026 - 3:08pm Nabawi ni Sen. Raffy Tulfo ang tatlong relong nagkakahalaga umano ng mahigit P15 milyon na ninakaw sa NAIA. OpinionNAIARAFFY TULFOSENATE OF THE PHILIPPINES next Recommended Tax evasion vs VP Sara, nasilip ng prosecution Nasilip ng House prosecution panel ang posibleng tax evasion ni Vice President Sara Duterte matapos umanong madiskubre ang P111.85 milyong hindi pagtutugma sa pagitan ng kanyang idineklarang kita at mga depositong pumasok sa bangko, batay sa mga dokumentong iniharap kaugnay ng nakabinbing impeachment trial sa Senado. 1 day ago SARA DUTERTE Senado at Kamara, pinagkokomento ng SC sa impeachment threshold ni VP Sara Inatasan ng Korte Suprema ang Senado at Kamara na magsumite ng kanilang komento sa petisyong inihain nina Sen. Robin Padilla at Sen. Bong Go na kumukuwestiyon sa ruling ng impeachment court hinggil sa voting threshold na kinakailangan upang mahatulan si Vice President Sara Duterte. 1 day ago SARA DUTERTE PANOORIN: NLEX C5 Northlink toll-free hanggang katapusan ng taon — Marcos Libre hanggang katapusan ng taon ang pagdaan sa bagong bukas na NLEX C5 Northlink, ayon kay Marcos. 1 day ago BONGBONG MARCOS INFRASTRUCTURE NLEX Barbers kay VP Sara: Ipaliwanag P81.84 milyong insurance, investments Hinamon ni House impeachment trial adviser at spokesperson Robert Ace Barbers si Vice President Sara Duterte na ipaliwanag ang umano’y P81.84 milyong transaksyon sa insurance at investments nila ng kanyang asawang si Atty. Manases “Mans” Carpio. 2 days ago SARA DUTERTE PANOORIN: P15-M na mga relo, ninakaw sa NAIA; mga opisyal, na-Tulfo! Nabawi ni Sen. Raffy Tulfo ang tatlong relong nagkakahalaga umano ng mahigit P15 milyon na ninakaw sa NAIA. 2 days ago NAIA RAFFY TULFO SENATE OF THE PHILIPPINES OK Are you sure you want to log out? Yes No X Login Philstar.com is one of the most vibrant, opinionated, discerning communities of readers on cyberspace. With your meaningful insights, help shape the stories that can shape the country. Sign up now!
